CHAD GADYA

DURING THE BITTER FEUD BETWEEN HARAV YONASAN EIBSCHUTZ AND HARAV YAAKOV EMDEN 

HE OVERHEARD SOME JEWS SPEAKING AGAINST HIM, HE TURNED TO THEM AND SAID.

I HAVE HAD A QUESTION ON THE CHAD GADYA SONG

I UNDERSTAND THAT THE CAT DID WRONG BY EATING THE HELPLESS KID.

SO THE DOG WAS RIGHT IN BITING THE CAT.

IF SO THE STICK WAS WRONG TO BEAT  THE DOG.

THE FIRE WAS RIGHT TO BURN UP THE STICK.

THE WATER HAD NO RIGHT TO QUENCH THE FIRE.

THE OX WAS RIGHT IN DRINKING THE WATER.

THE SHOCHET SHOULD NOT HAVE SLAUGHTERED OX.

THE MALACH HAMAVES WAS CORRECT IN KILLING THE SHOCHET.

IF SO WHY WILL HASHEM SLAUGHTER THE MALACH HAMAVES, HE WAS CORRECT

SO WE MUST SAY THAT HASHEM WAS RIGHT AND THE MALACH HAMAVES WAS WRONG

SO IT WORKS OUT THE DOG IS WRONG, BUT THE CAT DID EAT THE HELPLESS KID, THE REASON THE DOG IS WRONG AS ONLY A DOG GETS INVOLVED IN OTHER PEOPLE'S DISPUTES.